A pristine classic meter in the hand is worth two digital meters in the shop window!
or
What to expect when we measure with a classic handheld meter?



But remember it is the eye of the beholder that is the most important tool, combined with the human brains. In this command center the final area will be chosen and defined as middle-gray (Kodak test card).

If all fails, we can say: "We've found the problem ..It is us"

I could tell you stories...here is just one - On a Seminar I met this guy, doing B&W photography for more than 6 years, complaining about emulsions as he had most of the time very thin negatives, forcing him to use grade 4 most of the time. Questioning him about how he used the meter gave me a dumb look but it turned out he used incident light mode with his Minolta Autometer III. Nothing wrong with that if you know how... (Note: Working in incident mode requires correction of ISO - half the ISO value i.e use 50 ISO instead of 100 ISO to get the shadows a little more pronounced from filmbase plus fog - ) Well he was pointing the dome to the subject instead of the other way around i.e facing the camera!
It was very easy to point at the culprit instantaneously, hence his negs could be printed on grade 2 or 3 and came out nicely.
You have to understand what a meter really does....A reflected light exposure meter expects every scene will have a reflectance of 18% (Kodak Neutral test card).
If this is the case than your negatives will be okay, but...


Reflected Light
 
Incident Light

Most of the time scenes have much more tones, to get acquainted with this fast we have to go in deeper. It is like a "Right in your face, get your hands dirty" approach I must admit, but you will benefit from this knowledge for the rest of your life :-).

Select a white, gray(test card) and black subject or use cardboards (Do a closeup reading without casting a shadow of your meter). Measure each subject and expose for the meter recommendation(Arrow or pointer). Develop all the same time and evaluate all three negatives. You will quickly discover the density is the same for all three negatives.


    

Above you will see three cards : White - Gray - Black
Exposures were made using reflected light metering. Result, all cards have the same density! Imagine what it will do next time you make an exposure. To get pure white open up two stops - To get pitch black close down two stops.

This is the most important lesson and proof in your career as a photographer. There are lots of shuttertime/aperture combinations possible, however there is only one that will yield the correct exposed negative.


Knowing all this now, how do we proceed? There are a few possibilities, the most simple one is carry a Kodak Neutral Testcard with you all the time, measure the card and let the rest of the tones fall into their place.

Second one is the old rule : Expose for the shadows and develop for the highlights
We will speak about exposure, the development part maybe later...
What is a shadow and what is a highlight? Good question. We concentrate on the shadows for now(Most important part in B&W Neg)...We have to decide if we want detail in the shadow or not! If we decide for the first option, we will measure zone III and see what the meter says (remember it makes 18% grey)however we know this zone is two stops denser than Zone V. In stead of reading the value on Zone V we will use the mark Zone III and expose accordingly resulting in the correct density in the negative.
Example:
Meter readout is 1/60 @ f16.0 we will correct this by using 1/250 @ f16.0 (Two stops difference from Zone V (thus getting less density in negative resulting in Zone III in Print.
If you decide to expose for Zone IV (Much detail) you should expose 1/125 @ f16.0 (One stop from middle grey)>

If we wanted no detail (why should we do this? - pure theoretical) we should expose for Zone II resulting in an exposure of 1/500 @ f16.0 (Three stops from Zone V)

Zones differ one stop from each other as can be seen below. If you measure an important part in your photograph, decide in which tone you want it and correct your exposure accordingly.
After you've chosen your lowlight Zone, point your meter and see where the important high Zone falls. If the difference is more than 5 stops (log 1.50) we need to make corrections in the development time also!



Well this is nice Huh? We are in control....Actually this is only a primer, if you want to go any further, surf the WWW and search for "Zone System"
We did only talk about the metering, but you can imagine when contrast is very low or very high we have to do something with the development also.


If you go all the way and get the hang of the Zone System, don't become a slave of the system.
Moderate use and understanding of the system will pay off....but remember:

A print full of tones but empty of emotional content is as dull as a perfectly typed but meaningless manuscript.


Visualizing - Try to understand this Full-Tone subject.


Highslide JS
Examination of the different zones...
Visualization is very important if you strive for the perfect exposed negative.
In this example we did measure the wooden fence and moved the pointer to Zone III and exposed accordingly. Imagine what happened if we followed the meters recommendation (arrow - Zone V).

Take your time...(Some things in life can not be rushed and shouldn't be...a.o making a good Photograph)
Know what you want and what you are metering...

A very good book, we heartily recommend is: "The Negative" by Ansel Adams (ISBN 0-8212-1131-5)

One of my favorites is "Schwarzweiss-fotografie nach dem Zonensystem" Author Andreas Weidner. Verlag Photographie ISBN 3-7231-0041-4
Leider nur in Deutsch....and difficult to get!
If the language is no problem for you, in my view the best book on the system!

NOTE: OoP might be available used at Amazon.Com


The New Zone System Manual is the most extensive single book on the Zone System to date.  It shows how to bring all the variables of the photographic process under control.  The New Zone System Manual teaches the individual how to visualize the image before exposing the photograph.  It applies to all kinds of photographycreative, manipulative, multiple-image and multiple-exposure.

Minor White…Richard Zakia…Peter Lorenz…three experienced teachers and photographers combine years of training and experience to create this important book.  Their material is on method and techniqueand their approach is understandable for anyone seriously exploring black & white photography.  The New Zone System Manual features a sensitometry for working photographers that can lead to a deeper understanding of the nature of photography.  For amateurs and professionals, this method of image control can be applied for consistent fine quality in straight photography or experimental photography.  Any photographer who knows the essentials of exposure meter use, developing, and printing can master the Zone System.

NOTE: OoP (Out of Print) Available used at Amazon.COM


Visualizing - PinPoint metering.

Solution: A Spot Meter

       Highslide JS
Minolta Space meter
       Highslide JS
Minolta Spotmeter I


Highslide JS

Minolta Spotmeter II
If you really want to be in control, you will need a Spot meter
Shown on the left are the space meter and the first commercial meter from Minolta, a direct descendant of the meter used on the moon.

If you see the example image above where different zones were marked and placed, it might be clear that this is not possible with a normal averaging meter. The measuring angle is not small enough.


The second meter is the Minolta auto spot II, Ideal is a 1° Spometer as shown here.
Caution though, one needs to know what part to measure, understanding the zones and lots of experience with these meters!


A spotmeter and viewing filter are the mandatory tools to measure areas as shown.

Just to name some brands; Minolta, Pentax, Soligor, Sekonic Spot, Gossen Spot.
Several meters with a 5° or 10° accessory are suitable also. Note: Ansel Adams used a Weston Ranger 9 with a 18° angle for most of his landscape scenes.

Both meters pop-up regularly on Ebay at a fraction of the cost....


"The New Zone System Manual" by White,Zakia and Lorenz is completely based on the Weston Ranger 9

Note the integrated Zone Calculator

Weston Ranger 9
The Weston ranger 9, used frequently by Ansel Adams (Remark: If he did not forget to bring it along - Moon over Hernandez).
Note the Zone system scales on this meter.
And also the candlles per sq foot values assigned to the arbitrary numbers.
This is a CDS meter, though a little difficult to find the proper batteries , it is very precise and can measure reflected light (18 degrees window) and incident light as well. (Note the small dome)


Visualizing - Difficult as we see color all the time in real life.

Solution: The Panchromatic viewing filter

Panchromatic Viewing Filter #1. Besides determining lighting contrast, the Panchromatic Viewing Filter also shows the effective tonal separation within the scene. Color that seem to blend together when viewed through the Filter will, likewise, show no separation when photographed. If tonal separation is desired a suitable corrective filter should be used on the camera lens.


The Viewing filter is a great help to determine zones and contrast as well.
Nowadays available through TIFFEN and SPECTRA.


Viewing filter II.

Solution: How does it work?

Click on the image on the left to see the Mouseover version. In the first image the flower stands out very well against the background. This will look very different if you use Panchromatic film.
Note the bright colors that blend with the background. Without correction the photograph would look very dull indeed!


Besides determining lighting contrast, the Panchromatic Viewing Filter also shows the effective tonal separation within the scene. Colors that seem to blend together when viewed through the Filter will, likewise, show no separation when photographed. If tonal separation is desired a suitable corrective filter should be used on the camera lens.

In practice you hold the filter for your eye while looking and studying the zones and contrast.
As the eye adapts very quickly, move the filter in front and away from the eye at short intervals.


Below is some more info...I modified this Weston Master V somewhat so I can more easily explain novices what real measuring is about...
Study the scales and read some definitions about the zones, it will help you visualize the Zones in practice.
Have fun...Expose for the Magic and develop for the Surprises...

NOTE:: The reason I've chosen the Weston Master is a personal one.. (I feel a meter from the same era would be more appropriate).
Actually the Weston Master available in 1955 was the Weston Master III. It did read Cd/ft2 directly.
A very good choice might be the weston Master IV, the very last meter reading Cd/ft2
It speaks for itself you can use any meter you fancy, more important however is you know how to operate and interpret correctly! If you don't want to do mental conversions for bellows draw and filter factors there is the film plane meter.
Generally speaking there are 4 modes of light measuring, each mode has its own advantages and drawbacks.




Weston Master V adapted for easy reading Zones.
A little grey scale was glued inside, showing ZONE II - ZONE VIII. ZONE III has been marked with a black line corresponding with the black dot on the scale. ZONE VII has been marked with a red line corresponding with the red dot on the calculator scale.
Please note: These meters are averaging type meters, thus to measure important parts in the scene you have to go in and do a close reading while avoiding shadows casted by the meter.


Highslide JS
Zone II
II - Dark gray-black, possibility of slight texture, you think you see it - maybe. Mostly gradation.
Highslide JS
Zone III
III - Important Zone, very dark gray, but good texture and detail can be seen. Dark textured bark on shadow side of tree. Where you will probably want to "place" your shadow details. Darkest detail and texture.

Zone III example:
When detailed shadows are called for, we do a close reading of this object only and align the dial with the black dot against the found number(13)

Highslide JS
Zone IV
IV - Medium-dark gray, dark green foliage, shadow side of Caucasian skin. Details plainly visible.
Highslide JS
Zone V
This is Zone V representing KODAK Neutral grey card.(A standard reference for exposure evaluation and grading. The card is comprised of a large 18% neutral grey area ). This is the pivotal zone when measuring.

Clear north sky (panchromatic rendering). Dark skin. Gray stone. Average weathered wood. Middle gray (18% reflectance)

Highslide JS
Zone VI
VI - Rich mid-tone gray, average Caucasian skin in sunlight, shadowed snow on bright sunny day, sharp fine detail visible.
Highslide JS
Zone VII
VII - Bright light gray, highest Zone that will still hold good details. Weathered white paint, silver hair. VIII - Light gray-white, shows last texture (minimum) but no detail. Reflected highlights from light colored skin, textured snow in sun. Gradation exist.

Zone VII example:
Checking highlight: if we want still some detail here, we make a close reading of this object only and align the dial with the red dot against the found needle value. Please note this is only done to see where the highlights fall...If the difference is more or less than 4 stops with the ZONE III value we have to compensate with development time.

Highslide JS
Zone VIII
VIII - Almost white, must be compared to white to tell difference, no detail or significant texture visible. Lightest gradation values.




Weston Master IV, V, Weston Euro, Euromaster, Euromaster II .
Any one of these meters would make a fantabulous companion for your Combo!
No more guesstimates...



Measuring incident light - straightforward?
Not quite.....
Actually this is the same as measuring the Neutral Gray test card from Kodak with a reflected light meter, one exception though you need only one hand!
When we measure the light falling upon the subject, instead of measuring the reflection we still need to compensate for the subjects we measure.

Generally speaking we can say:
#1 If the subject is unusually light, decrease the calculated exposure by 1/2 to 1 stop.
#2 If the subject is unusually dark, increase the calculated exposure by 1/2 to 1 stop.

When using Black & White film it is advisable to adapt your Iso setting 1/2 to 1 stop lower, to raise the dark zones a little more above filmbase and fog.
Note: also when working with the incident light meter, our eyes and perception remain very important.



Addendum
Some thoughts on LF Photography:

Don't get obsessed with the weight of a camera. If you are going to take pictures in the field, you'll be carrying a large tripod, film holders, lenses, a dark cloth, a light meter, and all the chowder that goes with taking pictures. Plus chances are you'll also be toting another smaller format camera. So all that will probably weight in the neighborhood of 20 pounds, and probably even more. So what's the difference between 22 pounds and 25 pounds? Not much.

* Slow down, take your time, and work methodically. There are more ways to screw up than you can imagine. The quickest way to mess up is to try to save time and work quickly. There are times when you have to work fast, like when the light is changing, But in general, large format photography is slow and deliberate. If you come up with a system and stick with it, you'll ruin a lot less film.


Using filters and Bellows draw will influence your exposure time dramatically...

When using filters it is straightforward once you know the filter factor - just multiply this factor by your exposure time.

Bellows draw is a little more complicated. You will find many formulae elsewhere on this site.
We've found this one the most simple and easiest to remember: (BE:FL)2= BEF where:

  • BE = Bellows extension
  • FL = Focal length
  • BEF = Bellows exposure factor

Oh, you've noticed already? Yes, I like archaic tools, hence don't call me old fashioned though, I use an Ipod also :-)

I use my slide rule and apply mental arithmatic but feel free to use your Mobile Phone, PDA, calculator, coffee machine or whatever....
Bellows extension - measured from the middle of the lens (place of diaphragm) to the filmplane. In our example this is 250mm.
250:178(Aero Ektar 178mm) = 1.4
This is the compensation in f stops, if you need the BEF use the square number = 1.9

On the left you can see how it looks on our pocket slide rule (Those things don't need any batteries and are 99.5% accurate)
Note: The slide rule is from the same era as my AE - 1944.

Example II:
Bellows extension is 356. Our lens is the AE 178mm.
Seasoned LF shooters know immediately the outcome. Shown for your examination on our slide rule also...:-)
While making the photographs and adjusting the slide rule I've found when BE= 100 , the BEF is about when working with the Aero Ektar 7In.
This is sheer magic indeed....

NOTE: Practically the largest bellows draw when working withe AE - 314mm from the diaphragm to the filmplane.
Thus the magnification=0.76 - Exposure factor=3.14 - stops down 1.6


To get the magnification mentioned above get the front standard flush with the bed as shown.
NOTE: Practically the largest bellows draw when working withe AE - 314mm from the diaphragm to the filmplane.

Thus the magnification=0.76 - Exposure factor=3.14 - stops down 1.7
N O T E :: In case of emergency 360mm can be reached getting a ratio 1:1 !!

In this image you can see how far to rack the bed out to the front. The back of the frontpanel base should stop just before 8ft.
These examples are only valid if you did mount the Aero our way....
We love to see the results made with the Pi extension.


Reciprocity Law Failure Exposure Compensations
(Compiled from literature published by Ansel Adams and others)
INDICATED EXPOSURE: 1   *   *  2   *  *   4 *  *   8   *   *   15   *   *   30   *    *    60    *    *   120s
T-MAX 100:1  1.5  2 2.5  3  4  6  7  9  11 15 20  27  37  50  65  84  105 130 160 196 233
T-MAX 400:1  1.5  2  3   4  5   7  9 12 15 20 27  37  51  70 95  132 180 240 330 450 610
Polaroid Type 55:               3            6         15    25    36    65    90     140    204              504



Forgot your meter? Remembering this might just save your shot...!
Sunny 16 Rule

Almost every sheet film box has a leaflet with an exposure guide printed on it, which is based (with occasional slight variations) on the 'sunny 16' rule. This tells you to set the shutter speed to 1/film speed (using the ASA part of the ISO film speed; so with a ISO 400/27 film you set the speed to 1/400 - or rather the nearest fraction to this, 1/500). The required aperture can then be found as follows:

  • * bright sun - f16
  • * hazy sun - f11
  • * shade on sunny day or cloudy but bright - f8
  • * dull weather - f5.6



As the Sun is illuminating the Moon ,the above rule applies also for capturing the Moon

FULL MOONEY 11- For proper exposure of a full moon, set your aperture on 11 and your shutter speed as close to your films ISO rating as possible.
NOTE: Close but no cigar...
Checked this with my spotmeter at full moon (8-9-2006) Measured time was 1/125 (100 ISO) @ f11.0 To get it properly in Zone VII, we must use 1/60@ f8
HALF MOONEY 8- Use the above rule for shutter speed and use an aperture of 8 for pictures of a half moon.
QUARTER MOONEY 5.6- Use the above rule for shutter speed and use an aperture of5.6 for pictures of a quarter moon.




Completely off topic....?

Minolta III meter and Booster II

Highslide JS
Minolta Flashmeter III with Minolta Booster
Probably off topic....maybe, but I enjoy this meter very much, not only as a backup though. When doing close-up metering it allows me to do a reflected light reading from small important subjects.
This is extremely important when photographing single flowers.

Unplugged the meter gives me very accurate incident light readings.


Completely off topic (2)....?

Minolta original flash meter

Highslide JS
Minolta Flash meter (1969)
Certainly off topic....but fun.
In between editing the site, I've acquired this Minolta flash meter from 1969, complete with synch cord (never used and probably already worth the greens I've paid), manual and ND filter.
Aware of this meter since I studied on the Photo Academy, it was far beyond my reach in that time, I felt some quickening of the blood when spotting it on E-bay...

This was the very first professional flash meter. Actually a misnomer as ambient light can be measured also.
The meter can read reflected light (10 deg) and incident light with or without sync cord. The meter was in almost pristine condition. There could be a problem however, meters from this era used mercury 1.35 V exclusively. The substitute alkaline 625 1.5 V could give problems, but it did not.....The meter is dead-on compared to my Minolta IV.
Highslide JS
Minolta Flash meter (1969) Front-view
View from the measuring front.
Once the reflected light receptor view finder is attached the incident light receptor (dome) is disconnected.
The images will show its almost mint state the meter is in.
Highslide JS
Minolta Flash meter (1969) Front-view & back view
On the left: Correct position (Incident light) pointing to the camera.
On the right: Correct position (Reflected light) when pointing to the subject with the 10 deg viewfinder

It is very nice to handle this meter and certainly will cause raised eyebrows with my colleagues but... what the heck!

Highslide JS
Optional accessories in Minolta Box (1969)

Miscellaneous accessories acquired some time later:
  • Minolta accessory box
  • Accessory connector shoe
  • 4 EV ND filters for both incident and reflected light
  • Flat diffusor
  • Micro-Disk receptor LH2 5 LV more senstive than incident light receptor


Highslide JS
Original sales brochure (1969)
Copy from the sales leaflet 1969.
The meter was #1 choice till 1975 for professional Studio use, followed by the Minolta flashmeter II (1975-1979), Minolta Flash meter III (1979-1985 Probably the most respected Flash meter ever), Flashmeter IV (1985 - 1995), Flash meter V (1995-2002) and the Flash meter VI (2002 - a little short of forever?).

(Minolta Co Ltd and later Konica Minolta has stopped production of cameras and meters for the photographic market.)

  • Ref view finder
  • 4 EV ND filters for both incident and reflected light
  • Spherical and flat diffusors
  • Pin point receptor - measuring GG
  • Micro-Disk receptor


For some reason I kept this leaflet for many years in my archives.




Formulae
Meters for your Combo
Exposure Metering
Meter Calibration
Asking a Photograph
Misc Polaroid holders




 Legal!  About  Whois  Aldis  Aero Project  The Workout  Memorandum  Encounter...  Graflens  Lenses+  Holes+  My Pacemaker SG's  Books  Graflinks  Speedlights  Gallery  WICF  B&W film  Contact  Filmholders  Start Page  Whatsnew